In a very forceful advisory, the California Attorney General has made it clear that California law does not allow suppliers to micromanage and control distributor licensees.  This guidance apparently went to over 600 importers and suppliers. 
The staff of the attorney general actually  spent time reviewing the proposed supplier contracts to state law and were very concerned about [...]

Posted February 15, 2010 by admin under 21st Amendment, Alcohol Regulation, Alcohol Review, Guest Columns

A motion for summary judgement was filed by the plaintiffs in the Cap’n Cork case.   Recently Indiana  filed its cross motion for summary judgement.  The recent Wine Country 5th Circuit case as well as the Buy-Rite case from New York in the 2nd Circuit and the other Indiana case, Baude  at the 7th Circuit all heavily [...]

Posted February 15, 2010 by admin under 21st Amendment, Alcohol Review, Dormant Commerce Clause

Iowa has recently joined the ranks of states having a federal court determining the future of its state alcohol laws.  Indiana University Professor James Tanford has filed another Dormant Commerce Clause lawsuit this one challenging provisions in the Iowa alcohol code dealing with reciprocity for direct shipping.  A copy of this lawsuit can be found here.   By [...]

Posted January 21, 2010 by admin under 21st Amendment, Alcohol Review, Dormant Commerce Clause

Well the sordid ten year history of the TFWS case is over.  There will be no appeal to the United States Supreme Court.   In order to save the state money from attorneys fees, the state will not appeal in exchange for not having to pay attorney fees.  In a fee settlement agreement filed with the court the [...]

Posted January 13, 2010 by admin under 21st Amendment, Alcohol Regulation, Alcohol Review, Supreme Court

While I was at the Center for Alcohol Policy’s annual legal symposium, the Supreme Court denied certiorari in  Virginia v. Harris.    This was a petition seeking review of a 4-3 Virginia Supreme Court decision that held that an anonymous tip of a suspected drunk driver was not sufficicent for a police officer to pull over the [...]

Posted October 21, 2009 by admin under Alcohol Review

UPDATE:  The Supreme Court has denied certiorari in this 6th Circuit matter.  Cert denial can be found here.
Update:  TN brief below.   Supreme Court to decide whether to take this the week of September 29, 2009.
A pairing of lawyer and wine connoisseur has lead to the U.S. Supreme Court  being asked whether limitations imposed by Tennessee [...]

Posted October 5, 2009 by admin under 21st Amendment, Alcohol Regulation, Alcohol Review, Dormant Commerce Clause, Supreme Court

Washington Liquor Control Board filed its notice of appeal to the 9th Circuit on the issue of paying nearly all of the attorney fees to Costco despite winning 7/9 of  the litigation.  Their notice is here.   Also, the Washington Beer & Wine Wholesalers Association filed their notice of appeal as well.  Their appeal is here.
The chilling [...]

Posted September 17, 2009 by admin under 21st Amendment, Alcohol Regulation, Alcohol Review

There is a new Illinois lawsuit seeking to stop the recently enacted increases in beer, wine and spirits taxes.   There are several arguments advanced in the complaint.  Of interest to me is its discussion of beer taxes vs. wine/liquor taxes.  In a new twist on the long running equilization debate, the plaintiff claims it is [...]

Posted September 1, 2009 by admin under Alcohol Regulation, Alcohol Review

Very disappointing but not surprising decision from 4th Circuit today ruling against the state on the Maryland laws on price posting , price holdand quantity discount ban.   This decision seemed to be a certainty when an entire new panel of 4th Circuit judges came out for oral argument.   Personally, I think the court just wanted to [...]

Tags: 4th Circuit, Costco, liquor regulations, Maryland, NBWA, oral arguments, Sherman Anti trust
Posted July 15, 2009 by admin under 21st Amendment, Alcohol Regulation, Alcohol Review, Supreme Court

A very impressive win for New York today as the Second Circuit rejected a challenge by an out-of-state retailer seeking to sell to NY consumer.   In a strong opinion by Circuit Judge Wesley and a very informational concurrence by Circuit Judge Calabresi, the Second Circuit rejected the claims of the plaintiff.   The decision notes that [...]

Posted July 1, 2009 by admin under 21st Amendment, Alcohol Regulation, Alcohol Review, Dormant Commerce Clause, Supreme Court